Saturday, December 8, 2007

Prep Time

To be done: End the poem with a clever closing hook.

Stride up to the microphone confidently.
Raising my voice, ask the opening question of my poem.
Pause.
Allow the audience to consider the ambiguity in how I phrased the question.
Give a self-deprecating answer that dodges the issue,
then start to give the real answer.
Resolve the phrasal ambiguity of the question
by signaling which paradigm I'm answering in.
Go into the list portion of the poem, as a single compound sentence.
Emphasize the word "or" between list items.
Speed up and get louder as the list goes on.
Finish the list by concluding the compound sentence.
Counterpoint the compound sentence with items not on the list, emphasizing the word "and".
Reiterate question with summary of answer.
End the poem with a clever closing hook.


Why don't I tell people that I don't believe in God?

One answer is that I don't tell people much of anything,
I don't really talk to people that much...
But really, it's about definitions.
If someone wants to think that I really do believe in God after all,
or that I'm objectively wrong not to,
then over the course of a discussion
the meanings of the words "believe" and "God" end up shifting.
If you define "believe in" to mean "otherwise respect people who differ on the issue of",
or define "God" to mean "the neurological sensation of an unseen presence",
or define "believe in" to mean "not have a direct incontrovertable disproof of",
or define "God" to mean "the fact that there are things mankind doesn't know",
or define "believe in" to mean "acknowledge the social significance of",
or define "God" to mean "the possibility of an intelligence predating humans",
or define "believe in" to mean "consider a comforting, warm idea",
or define "God" to mean "the mental act of prayer",
or define "believe in" to mean "appreciate as a narrative trope",
or define "God" to mean "the emotion of love",
or define "believe in" to mean "use in a thought experiment",
or define "God" to mean "ethics",
then you can get from there to a situation where I believe in God.
But if we agree to define "God" as the word's used in everyday non-academic speech,
and to define "believe in" in the same way we'd use it when we're not talking about religion,
then I don't believe in God.
I don't tell people that I don't believe in God
because saying all that takes too long and comes across confrontational.
End the poem with a clever closing hook.

No comments: