Friday, December 14, 2007

Plausible Revisions

Hi.
I have a story to tell you that's implausible,
so you'll have reach into the back of your mind,
find your suspension of disbelief knob,
and turn it clockwise about three-quarters.
Okay, everyone suspending disbelief?
Great.

Once upon a time, in New England, in the early eighties,
there was a very small girl who had an innate urge to create.
Many children have this urge.
Maybe all of them, but it seems stronger in some than in others.
And, as is common in childhood,
this very small girl fell in love with a particular kind of creation.
This very small girl in the early eighties fell in love with paintings.
She would fill her mind with everything there was to know about paintings,
about paintings of every kind,
about classic paintings and about contemporary paintings,
and about the act of painting
and about every process and tool that goes into making a painting,
and she made her own paintings,
and she was good at it,
and grownups would watch her mixing paints and measuring paints
to get just the right colors and effects she wanted,
and they would tell her "You're so good at mixing and measuring.
You must want to be a chemist when you grow up!"
and she kept at painting, learning everything there was to learn about paint,
learning exactly what she needed to do to produce every effect she could produce,
and she learned about other kinds of art too,
music and writing and sculpture and dance and photography,
but she loved painting most of all.
Much later, in the mid-nineties, it was time for her to go to college,
and this little girl,
now a young woman,
loved paint so much that she majored in chemistry,
and she was very good at it.

Okay, suspension of disbelief off.
The story doesn't work, does it.
Paintings are art, not chemistry.
And in this setting, early eighties New England, everyone knows that.
And there are art schools to go to to learn all about painting.
So it doesn't make sense that grownups would see this little girl mixing and measuring
and say "You must want to be a chemist".
They'd say "You must want to be an artist when you grow up."
Still... I don't want to throw this story out.
Maybe we can salvage it!

Let's try this.
Let's go back into the early Eighties and make an edit.
Let's edit "paintings" to "video games".
Then we can edit "mixing and measuring" to "programming".
And now we're getting somewhere.
In the early eighties, no one was even asking if video games were art.
The people who made video games were never called artists.
So if someone saw this little girl mixing and measuring computer code,
instead of paint,
they'd say "You must want to be a computer programmer when you grow up",
not "You must want to be an artist."
Yeah. That works.
Edit "paintings" to "video games",
then go forward to the nineties and she becomes a computer science major.
That's plausible.
The story could happen, that way.

So, story fixed. No need to suspend disbelief for this version.
Hm... while we're at it, let's just make one more change.
It shouldn't make a difference,
but let's go back to the late Seventies,
T minus nine months,
and let's replace "girl" with "boy".
Not that there should be any difference at all,
but let's just throw that in there.
And I have no idea whether this boy lives happily ever after.
The end.

No comments: