Wednesday, July 4, 2007

My reactions to art

Highly beautiful: After the initial emotional effect of the work passes, I'm left sad because I want to create beauty, not just observe it myself.

Average quality with Hollywood production values: Sad because I think of all the resources that went into it and all the talented people who had to take their time getting things technically right just to make something utterly ephemeral. Some people get to have all this power to create, even though their ideas are no better than mine, just because they're in the right place at the right time and know how to network.

Low quality: I feel sad here too, this time because of the feeling that I could have done a better job myself if I were just willing to put in the effort to create.

Average-quality with inexpensive production values: Soothing in a transitory way. I can get into something if I feel it's unpolished personal expression or that it's unpretentiously workmanlike. Of course, there's not much profundity to be found in such a work. The position and breadth of this sweet-spot category depend on medium. A quite small movie or straightforward song can feel overproduced to me, while a 2D video game can have quite a lot of polish and still feel unpretentious. Weirdly, it's possible for a piece of music or animation that I'd find overproduced on its own to appear in a video game and seem okay there.

My own past work, high quality: A mix of pride and fear. I know that I was capable of greatness in the past, and I worry that I might have somehow lost the knack.

My own past work, average quality: This category doesn't exist for me. I can't look at something I did without binning it as good or bad.

My own past work, low quality: Regret at wasted time, generally. For a few pieces, pride that I managed to make something at all under situational constraints.

So, in summary, I don't really enjoy taking in art. I want so badly to create, but I can't bring myself to. I don't have the arrogance (some people'd use the term "self-esteem") to make something and push it in people's faces, or to toil away for a long time on something I don't know will come out well. I don't have the selflessness to be a smoothly functioning part of a larger team making something. I need to change to create.

T&R is a work created behind a shield of incompetence. Instead of getting it right, I made getting it wrong part of the premise. This had some useful results artistically, but it's held me back psychologically. I internalized the jokes and made them part of my identity. That's the key to why it has to end as completely as I can manage the ending.

No comments: