Wednesday, July 4, 2007

The fundamental arrogance of art

To be an artist with any chance of drawing an audience, you have to be willing to tell someone "Despite there being decades or centuries of classic works before me, geniuses of all stripes in all media, more renowned brilliance than you could take in in your entire life, you should use your time to check out this new thing instead."

It's easier to say it in some media than others, since there's less competition in a new medium and a greater potential for the audience to find novelty (which is distinct from brilliance but easily mistaken for it). Still, even in video games, it's a thing you have to be willing to say.

Why can someone say it?
  • Ignorance of prior art: the artist believes that s/he has created something without precedent
  • Dishonesty + economic need: the artist wants money and will lie about the work's importance to get it
  • Dishonesty + emotional need: the artist wants attention and will lie about the work's importance to get it. Often, the artist is self-deceiving here, not only deceiving others.
  • Niche targeting: the work is conceived for a particular audience, and may be more appealing to that audience than anything prior because of that targeting.
  • Arrogance: the artist believes that his/her own work is in herently superior to that of others
  • Love of novelty: the artist considers older works inherently unworthy by virtue of their age, such that new works need not be held up against them. This is most prominent in media with a moving technical bar, such as video games.
  • Convenience: the artist has made the work available in a manner that classic works are not, such that the audience can experience it in situations inconsistent with the experience of the classic works
This whole idea is filled with holes, of course. I'm just posting it to see the holes poked.

No comments: